The Non-compassionate Vegan

Just leaves me cold

Just leaves me cold

Are vegans always “compassionate”?

I often feel I spend too much time on vegan Facebook groups for my own good. They can be wonderful places full of recipes, ideas, debates… more debates. Just about every debate ends up with someone wailing “Why are you arguing? Vegans should be compassionate!” They make the same claim when discussing those people who continue to exploit animals. “Everyone is on their own journey. Vegans should be compassionate!” The next thing you know they are talking about vibrations, negative energy and are signing off every post “namaste x” I think they may just do this to vex me.

On the face of it you can see where they are coming from. The decision to forgo eating meat and ice cream, wearing cool leather trousers and plastering your face in cheap cosmetics does suggest that you are putting the needs of another above those of your own and this could be a pretty good working definition of compassion. However… I am just not that compassionate a person. I don’t think I am really all that in to animals.

Clips on YouTube of cute kittens do nothing for me. I can watch a lion take down a gazelle and not even flinch. For me that is not what being a vegan is all about. Veganism is a perfectly rational position which states that we don’t have the right to exploit other animals for our own uses. That is it. It has nothing to do with being nice or kind or compassionate. It has nothing to do with making meat eaters feel all warm and fuzzy and unjudged. It has nothing to do with making those on a plant-based diet feel OK about their continued use of leather. Believing that rape is wrong doesn’t make you a compassionate person, just a person. If I say I am against genocide people won’t expect me to be a compassionate person, just a person. Saying it is wrong to exploit animals doesn’t make me a compassionate person, just an aware person.

What do you think? Have I missed the point? Am I nicer than I think I am?


2 thoughts on “The Non-compassionate Vegan

  1. I agree. People like to put others into categories – labelling them based on the little they know.
    Trialling veganism for a month and only a few days in, I already feel that people instantly judge me if I mention I am a vegan (one friend saying, isn’t being a vegetarian enough – I didn’t ask them what exactly they meant by enough, but I did think ‘enough of what exactly?!’ and a barman trying to tell me that a way to a mans heart is through his stomach so cooking a meat dish is the only way to win someones heart 😉 )
    Everyone is different, making choices for a wide range of reasons, so choosing not to eat meat does not necessarily make one a good all round person.
    Btw, your comment about the lion and gazelle – a lot of people don’t get the circle of life, they don’t want to see the gazelle get eaten, but they also don’t want to watch a lion die of starvation – I don’t flinch when a gazelle gets taken down either, it’s not nice, but it has to happen. However…your pic of the puppy, now that is simply adorable!!! 😀

  2. Pingback: Double negatives | Great Vegan Expectations

Views, comments, ideas and feedback are always welcome. Be good to hear from you.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s